The Presentation of the Blessed Virgin Mary
Homily Starter
Binding thread: John's two witnesses, apparently defeated and then raised, and Jesus's own answer to the Sadducees converge on a single claim: death does not have the final say over anyone genuinely alive to God, whether in vision or in doctrine.
Exegetical notes:
- The identity of Revelation's "two witnesses" (11:3-13) has been debated since antiquity; common interpretive traditions associate them with Moses and Elijah (both associated with plagues and fire, respectively, matching details in the text) or simply read them as symbolic of the Church's own prophetic witness under persecution.
- The Sadducees, who accepted only the five books of Moses as authoritative and rejected later doctrinal developments including bodily resurrection, construct their scenario using levirate marriage law from Deuteronomy 25:5-6, attempting to show the doctrine's supposed absurdity using Mosaic law itself.
- Jesus's answer (20:37-38) argues from Exodus 3:6, where God identifies himself to Moses as the God of the patriarchs using the present tense ("I am," not "I was") - a genuinely rabbinic style of argument from the text's own grammar, which would have carried real weight with a Sadducean audience specifically.
- The Presentation of Mary's liturgical origins trace to a feast celebrated in Jerusalem by at least the sixth century, commemorating the dedication of a church near the Temple Mount; the specific narrative of Mary's childhood presentation comes from the Protoevangelium of James, an early but non-canonical text.
Pastoral turn: Grief for the dead can quietly slide into treating them as simply gone rather than genuinely, presently alive to God; today's readings offer a direct, doctrinal corrective to that drift, and it deserves to be stated plainly rather than only implied.
Entry points: "The Sadducees thought they had a trap. Jesus simply pointed to the grammar of Exodus - God says 'I am,' not 'I was.'" / "Two witnesses lay dead in the street for three and a half days. That was never the end of the story."
Illustration prompt: Reflect on a specific name in your own parish's Book of Names this month, and what it means to actually believe that person remains alive to God right now.
Avoid: Presenting the Presentation of Mary as scriptural narrative; name it clearly as pious tradition while affirming the genuine devotional value it carries for the Church's life.
Downloads require a subscription.
Subscribe for Full Access